Tuesday, October 15, 2024

For Monday

Tuesday audio. Prelim Exam due next Tuesday in class.

Prep all of Process, Burdens, and Presumptions. What are presumptions and how do they operate? Why have presumptions--why does the law require the finding of a material fact from certain basic facts? See C&S p. 423 for some common presumptions. Consider how FRCP 50 motions fit into this. What is the purpose of factual presumptions? Work all the possible permutations in Question # 106 (on the death presumption);

Consider the following presumption and how it would work under FRE 301 and FRCP 50: A child born within 300 days of married opposite-sex couple living together as husband and wife shall be presumed to be the product of the marriage.

H sues W for custody and must prove paternity. Consider how the presumption operates on the following:

    1) H offers evidence that they were legally married, living as H&W, and the child was born within 300 days of their living together; W offers no evidence.

    2) H offers evidence that they were living as H&W and the child was born within 300 days, but no evidence they were legally married.

    3) H offers evidence they were legally married but no evidence they were living as H&W.

    4) H offers evidence that they were legally married, living as H&W, and the child was born within 300 days of their living together; W offers evid they were not legally married.

    5) H offers evidence that they were legally married, living as H&W, and the child was born within 300 days of their living together; W offers evidence they were not living as H&W.

    6) H offers evidence that they were legally married, living as H&W, and the child was born within 300 days of their living together; W offers evid that H had vasectomy, DNA evidence showing someone else as father, and evidence of an extra-marital affair.